Researching dog training collars for unwanted behavior may have you foaming at the mouth due to their “shock” treatment. Rest assured, though, that these devices have come a long way since they were first introduced and they no longer deliver painful electrical shocks to the animal wearing them.
If you’ve ever had an electronically stimulating massage pad put on you, you’ll understand the exact sensation that a pup feels when one of these is triggered. It doesn’t hurt, but it certainly noticeable enough to get the pup to pay attention and quit their bad behavior.
There are other types of collars available, though. Some use scents to deter your pup; some use sound or vibration. Even if you are still a little uneasy about “shock” collars, there will be something on this list that works for you.
- 100% WATERPROOF - IPX7 waterproof rating receiver with Durable ABS shell, TPU strap and...
- MULTIFUNCTION WIRELESS REMOTE - With LCD backlit display, 3 working modes: Tone, 1-16 levels of...
The biggest problem with shock collars is the human using them. When used properly, they can be an effective and non-harmful tool to train dogs. They can, however, be abused. Those should never be used to punish an animal. This kind of abuse is punishable by law.
We have included “shock” and no-shock training collars on this list. If you’re averse to the shock ones, you’ll still find value in this list. If you’re happy to give an electronic “shock” collar a try, we can vouch for them being perfectly safe if used correctly.
Let’s get right into it – the top 5 dog training collars that we’ve come across on the market.
5 Top Rated Dog Training Collars Table
|Recommendation||Dog Training Collar|
|Top Choice||WOLFWILL 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Humane No...|
|Runner Up||SportDOG Brand 425 Family Remote Trainers -...|
|Budget Choice||Dog Training Collar - New Upgraded Shock Collar...|
|Best For Small Dogs||Dogtra iQ Plus Remote Trainer|
|Best Simple Training Collar||PetSafe Gentle Leader Head Collar with Training...|
Our Top Choice: WOLFWILL Humane No-Shock Remote Dog Training Collar
The device works up to a distance of 660 yards and has 16 different intensities of vibration. The remote control can also be linked up to two collars at the same time, but you will need to buy the other one separately.
It’s also 100% waterproof, so you on’t have to worry about your furry friend taking a dive into the pool after some intense training!
- 100% waterproof
- 16 vibration intensity levels, plus tones and lights
- Up to 660 yards control distance
- The remote can be used with two collars (although you will have to buy a second separately)
- Auto-off saves battery power
- Splitter cable included for charging and remote simultaneously
- Includes belt clip, neck strap, and finger ring so you can carry it however is comfy for you
- 30-day money back guarantee
- 2-year warranty
- A leash cannot be attached directly to the collar – a second one or a harness is needed to be used in conjunction
- Only available for pups between 22 and 88 pounds (or with 9 – 19-inch necks)
- Doesn’t function automatically – needs the remote
Our Runner-Up Choice: SportDOG SD-425 Family Remote Trainer
- E-collar that features 500 yard range and can be used to train 3 dogs with the same Remote...
- The Remote Transmitter's dial allows you to instantly select one of the 7 levels of static...
The SD-425 FieldTrainer is an extremely versatile e-collar. This is a high-action, sporty device and can be programmed to work with up to 3 collars at one time, and is often used to train hunting dogs in the field.
The SD-425 can be submerged up to 25
The lithium-ion batteries charge fully in 2 hours, an last 50 – 70 hours per charge. the transmitter comes with a training DVD and operating guide, and customer support is available 6 days a week.
- Works with up to 3 collars at once
- Waterproof (both receiver and transmitter are submersible up to 25 feet)
- 500-yard range
- Works for dogs of various sizes
- 7 different levels of stimulation
- Choice of vibration and tone in addition to electric stimulation
- 2-hour quick charge
- Holds charge for up to 70 hours
- Additional products available from SportDOG
- Customer support available
- Plastic collar should not be left on for too long as it can cause irritation
- Problems have been reported with charging cables not fitting well
- Some reviews have indicated that the product doesn’t last more than a year or so
Best Budget Choice: My Reddog Dog Training Collar
This electronic collar works for dog trainers and dog owners who are novices when it comes to training. It’s water resistant, making it easy to use in any weather, and if you have a pup who loves swimming.
The device has 4 modes – beep, vibrate, LED light, and shock. The vibration and shock functions are adjustable on 10 levels. It can be set to go off automatically
You also get a free bright neon light bulb that hangs on your dog’s collar, so you’ll always know where they are in the dark!
- Water resistant
- 1000 foot range
- Great for pros and novices
- 4 correction modes
- Free gift!
- Sizes seem to run small, so buy one up!
Best Dog Training Collar For Small Dogs: Dogtra IQ Plus Remote Trainer
- 400-Yard Range
- Low to Medium Power Stimulation
Although this one does come in sizes for large dogs, it does cater for pups as small as 10 pounds. It is also
For little but fearless pups who enjoy a good swim, the collar is waterproof and works at a range of 400 yards. It can also be extended to work with a second one, if you have another dog that needs the same training.
Modes of operation
This electronic device has 3 different stimulation modes to choose from – Nick, which is a sharper, sudden sensation, Constant, which is a more drawn out stimulation, and Pager, which is a vibration similar to what you would have on a cellphone. The collar outputs a low to medium stimulation that can be controlled on 100 levels using Dogtra’s patented Rheostat Intensity Dial.
One of the reasons we’ve chosen this as our best choice for small dogs is the vibration option – small dogs especially are more sensitive to sensations. This collar has enough choice of stimulation to be a great option for smaller, more sensitive, and perhaps more fearful dogs. It’s also more compact than most, meaning it’s lighter and easier for your pooch to wear.
- For pups as small as 10 pounds
- Waterproof (receiver as well)
- 400-yard range
- Compact and easy for small dogs to wear
- Use for 2 collars at once
- 3 stimulation modes (including a non-shock, vibrate option)
- Low to medium stimulation level
- 2-hour quick charge time
- 1-year warranty
- The collar is stiff and can be uncomfortable for a dog
- No bark control component
- No auto-off function
Best Simple Dog Training Collar: Petsafe Gentle Leader Head Collar
- Enjoy stress-free walks with the PetSafe Gentle Leader No-Pull Headcollar; Perfect for training...
- Stops excessive leash pulling and prevents other unwanted behaviors like lunging, jumping and...
This simple, no-fuss collar is designed for one function – teaching your dog to walk on a leash. With options for dogs from 5 pounds to 130
With one loop around the muzzle and one around the back of the head, this collar provides immediate, gentle control over the direction your dog is walking and how close they are to you.
It’s safe and can be adjusted to fit your dog, so it doesn’t cause pain or choking. The placement of the muzzle loop is also such that your pup can still open their mouth to eat, drink, or pant.
- Simple and easy to use
- Available for all size dogs
- Available in multiple colors
- Made from nylon
- Gives gentle yet firm control
- Allows pup to open mouth comfortably
- Includes fitting instructions, training guide, and DVD
- Not suitable for more complex training
If you’re looking for a training collar for your dog, there are a few things you should check out before you buy one and start using it.
Not all dogs are going to react the same way to collars, so it is important that you are aware of your dog’s nature and personality. Some dogs are going to require more strict and strenuous training, and some are going to take to it right away simply because they are more timid.
How To Choose The Right Training Collar For Your Dog
- Know Your Dog
If your dog is rowdy and hard to control, you will most likely need something that will catch his attention and keep it. An electronic collar with a bit of a static correction might be best.
If you have a quiet, timid pup who simply needs some direction, a non-shock collar may be the option to go for.
- Test The “Shock” On Yourself
Yes – if you feel it, your dog will feel it more. Put the collar on yourself (yes, on your throat), and let it zap you with static electricity. If you are too scared to do this, would you really put it on your dog on the off-chance that it may hurt him?
Test the vibrate intensity on yourself as well. You want to have a good idea of where to begin with levels of shock and vibration, instead of testing it out on your poor pup until you get it to an appropriate intensity.
- Consider What Type Of Training You Want To Do
There are various behavioral problems you can address with electronic collars. Barking, chasing, learning perimeters, obedience, or avoiding areas are a few common ones.
Training your dog to stop unnecessary barking doesn’t need as intense a collar as training a large dog to stop being aggressive would.
- Always Remember To Give Positive Reinforcement
Training sessions should NOT be a punishment for your furry friend. Whatever the behavioral issue you’re trying to rectify, your training method should always include reward when your pup gets it right.
Positive reinforcement means getting your pet to associate good behavior with reward and wanting to behave better for that reason. This should always be the aim – focusing on the positive, rather than the negative.
Collars should reinforce this, instead of leading your pet to associate certain behavior with pain or punishment. When your pet sees the collar, they should anticipate fun and rewards – not fear and pain. Used correctly, this can be super effective!
Frequently Asked Questions
With the advancement of technology, shock collars have become quite safe for pets. They don’t deliver an electrical “shock”, as such. It is more a low to medium intensity electrical stimulation similar to what you might feel using electronic massage pads. This is usually more uncomfortable to pets than painful.
Test it on yourself. If you can’t handle it, your pet won’t handle it. If it’s moderately uncomfortable for you, it is likely to be highly uncomfortable for your pet.
Most of the collars reviewed indicate that they can be used from 6 months. Again, though – you know your pup best, so take into account your pet’s temperament.
Other Dog Training Collars We Reviewed
- Best No-Bark Dog Training Collars
- Best Barrier Training Dog Collars
Some collars do a great job at certain functions or for certain dogs. Sometimes, we need to get a bit of specific to make sure we end up with the right training collar, both for our purpose, and for our pup.
Best No-Bark Dog Training Collars
Petsafe Spray Bark Collar
- NO BARKING OR WHINING: The PetSafe Spray Bark Dog Collar uses a burst of spray to help stop...
- FITS SMALL TO LARGE DOGS: The collar is designed for dogs 8 lb. and up and is adjustable for...
A no-shock no bark collar that gives off a spray to deter your pup from unnecessary barking or whining. Water resistant and fitting dogs from 8 pounds up, this collar is a simple, humane alternative to prevent noise.
The collar works on sound and vibration of your dog’s vocal cords, which triggers it to emit a burst of spray. This will usually startle your pup and stop the barking. The collar comes with one unscented spray and one citronella spray. Both are harmless for pups and humans and dissipate quickly.
- Recommended for pups 6 months or older
- Easy to use
- The collar is comfortable for dogs to wear
- You can trigger scent release by sound and vibration when dog barks
- The collar is rechargeable
- Each cannister holds 35 – 40 sprays
- Fits dogs with necks up to 27 inches in circumference
- Customer care is available 6 days a week
Best Barrier Training Dog Collars
Petsafe Stay & Play Wireless Fence
- WIRELESS BOUNDARY - keep your pets safely contained in your yard without having to dig or bury...
- COVER UP TO 3/4 ACRE - adjustable range up to 105 feet in all directions from the indoor...
This training set keeps your dog within a certain perimeter using an invisible fence system. It’s perfect not only for within your own yard but if you’re an adventurer who likes taking your dog with you when you travel.
This barrier uses flags that you can move around freely, as opposed to others that need to be buried. These can be spread out to a space of up to 105 feet in all directions, and this can be widened by purchasing additional transmitters.
This also works for multiple pets, provided they have a collar. There are 5 levels of static correction. When your pet approaches the edge of the zone, the collar emits a warning tone. If he persists, the collar will deliver a static correction. Be sure to set the static pulse to something appropriate for your dog.
- Portable and easy to set up
- Up to 105 feet perimeter
- Unlimited amount of pets at one time
- 5 correction levels
- Collar charges in 2 – 3 hours (and holds charge for up to 3 weeks)
- Customer support available 6 days a week
Petsafe Pawz Away Indoor Pet Barrier
- PROTECT YOUR BELONGINGS - teaches pets to avoid areas inside the home such as furniture,...
- ADJUSTABLE RANGE - barrier protects areas from 2 - 12 feet diameter from the barrier...
This barrier is more for keeping your pet away from a particular area than it is keeping them in one. The transmitter is placed in or near the area you want your pet to avoid, and when they come near it, the collar emits a series of tones to warn your pet off.
This will be accompanied by a set of progressive set of static corrections. This will stop when your pet leaves the area, or when the 15-second time-out is reached. Pets should learn quickly to avoid the area altogether!
There is also an outdoor option, a threshold option (for stairs), and you can buy extra transmitters and collars separately.
- Adjustable range (2 to 12 feet from the transmitter)
- Lightweight collar
- Auto safety shut-off (15 seconds)
- Adjustable collar (neck size from 6 to 28 inches)
- Only compatible with Pawz Away collars
The are many different dog training collars available out there to help change bad behavior. Simple, no-fuss leashes, remote control electronic collars controlled by the dog owner, and perimeter training collars that can be set up and require little input from the trainer.
Whatever your training requirements, you’ll find some kind of dog training collar that will cater for your (and your pup’s) needs. Don’t just leap into it unprepared though – do your research and make sure you get something appropriate.
Have you had success with other dog training collars? Let us know in the comments!